Living Kidney Donors Network
Compensating Kidney Donors
The only way to increase the number of kidney transplants is through more deceased and/or living donations. There have been many suggestions on how to increase the number of kidney transplants. Two of those proposals have received much attention. One which claims it will increase the number of deceased donors is presumed consent, where upon your death you are assumed to be an organ donor unless you previously opted out. The other is to compensate kidney donors. I'll discuss the compensation issue this month and presumed consent next month.
Much has been written, pro and con regarding the compensation question, but thus far no one has developed a comprehensive proposal for a regulated system in the United States. Iran has a State sponsered living donor compensation system in place. As strange as this may sound, they have a waiting list for donors. However, the culture in Iran is very different than in the United States.
An excellent book by Sigrid Fry-Revere describes the Iranian system. Sigrid is the only American to travel to Iran to investigate and interview hundreds of recipients, donors, physicians, nurses and administrators of their transplant system. The book is called "The Kidney Sellers" and is available at Amazon.
For the post 2 months I've been working with a organization to develop a position statement on compensating living kidney donors. The organization is called the Chicago Transplant Ethics Consortium. (CTEC) http://sites.surgery.northwestern.edu/ctec/index.htm CTEC feels that at this time it is ethical to do a study on compensating donors and is in the process of drafting such a document.
What I've found in working with CTEC is how many difficult questions need to be answered to develop a plan to compensate living donors. Developing such a policy will be very difficult and there's a large group of people who find the concept "repugnant." They intentionally use this word because of the strong negative feeling it conveys.
Here are a few recent articles about compensating organ donors, both pro and con.
Sally Satel, a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute and author of "When Altruism Isn't Enough" writes about "Why People Don't Donate Their Kidneys."
A University of Wisconsin doctor supports providing subsidized or free health insurance for living kidney donors.
A Nobel Prize winning economist from the University of Chicago and a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution describe how compensating donors will increas
e the number of kidney transplants.
Wesley Smith is a lawyer and author and writes that the government should not compensate kidney donors.
Help for your Kidney Kampaign
Tuesdays with... updates
I continue to receive good feedback from those using the weekly Tuesdays with... updates. To learn more about Tuesdays with... click here.
Recent Inspirational Stories
Would you like to read more inspirational stories? Then sign up for Google Alerts. Do a search for: "how to get Google Alerts" and you'll find simple instructions. You'll need to put in key words, i.e. kidney transplants, living donations, etc. and stories will be emailed to you. If you find one you'd like to share then post it on the LKDN Facebook page.
Hand written sign on her back telling of her story results in catching the eye of donor.
Glen Burnie waitress donates kidney to 2 year old boy
School worker donates to stranger.
What's happening on the LKDN Facebook page?
Within the next few days we will have 7,000 Facebook followers. Thank you for your continued support. Remember, every week we change our cover picture. If you want to honor your donor or recipient please send your JPEG picture and story to pic@LKDN.org so we can feature you!
Videos & Books
A Transplant for Katy
depicts the dramatic efforts to save a star patient – and the reputation of the world’s leading transplant center, where patients from as far as Egypt and Libya came in search of a miracle.
A Transplant for Katy
is the heartbreaking saga of a former homecoming queen who never realized she was expected to revolutionize medicine.
The book can be purchased on amazon.com
or directly from the website. www.transplantforkaty.com
| Medical Editor
Please Share this Newsletter
you know someone who could benefit from reading this newsletter, please forward it to them. You could share it with your dialysis or transplant social worker so they could pass it on to their patients.
To view previous newsletters Click Here